Sea of Thieves Best Weapons Tier List - Season 16

This guide gives a complete Sea of Thieves best weapons tier list to dominate each fight. The game gives every pirate the same set of tools, but some stand out. From classic cutlasses to sneaky poison darts, the title offers plenty of ways to fight.

Knowing which weapons are worth using can make every battle smoother. With only two slots to work with, picking the right combo really matters. This tier list breaks down all the best choices for every kind of player. Some weapons shine in close brawls, and others rule from a distance. Let’s explore Sea of Thieves best weapons 2025 in Season 16.

Tired of farming and grinding? SkyCoach can help you with Gold Farming in Sea of Thieves. Get the desired amount of the currency and buy whatever you want. We guarantee the best price and the fastest completion time for your order.

Check out more Sea of Thieves guides:

• Fastest Way to Make Money
• Beginner Guide

How Our Gun Tier List Works

Sea of Thieves lets players pick any weapon from the start. This means knowing what’s strong helps a lot. This tier list looks at each weapon’s performance in real fights, not just stats. Some shine in PvP, some rule in PvE, and a few do both. We judged each one based on damage, reliability, ease of use, and overall value in battle. You only get two weapon slots, so smart choices matter. Here’s how our Sea of Thieves gun tier list works:

• S-Tier: Top-tier weapons that feel strong in nearly every situation. They hit hard, perform well, and give a clear edge in PvP and PvE.
• A-Tier: Great options with strong performance, though not always the best. They shine in the right hands and work well for many playstyles.
• B-Tier: Decent picks that can hold their own but have some downsides. You may like them with the right strategy or combo.
• C-Tier: Low-impact weapons that are niche or situational. They can work, but there are better choices for most fights.

Note: Our tier list is constantly updated, especially when patches and new seasons are released. Make sure to check this guide once in a while to see what’s cooking.

Strongest Weapon in Sea of Thieves Overall

Eye of Reach is the strongest weapon in Sea of Thieves right now. It deals high damage, offers pinpoint accuracy, and lets skilled players dominate from a distance. A single shot takes out most of a health bar, making follow-up hits deadly. With practice, it works well even in close fights. It’s great for taking control early and keeping enemies at bay.

Still in doubt? Let’s see why Eye of Reach is so good in the current meta:

1. High precision at long range
2. Massive burst damage potential
3. Useful for both PvP and PvE
4. Can be paired with Cutlass for close defense

Its main drawback is the slow reload speed, but smart pirates can work around this. Use cover, reposition fast, and rely on a backup weapon when enemies close in. With a steady hand and some aim, Eye of Reach turns any pirate into a threat. Nothing else in the game offers this level of reach and stopping power in skilled hands.

Sea of Thieves Weapon Tier List

We’ve got all Sea of Thieves weapons ranked to define the strongest and weakest ones. This tier list gives precise information exactly for Season 16. After you see this, we’ll describe the best weapons. They belong to S and A tiers, meaning they deserve your attention more than any other gun on the table. Here’s our Sea of Thieves weapon tier list:

Yes, most weapons are not really worth your attention in the current meta. Therefore, we highly recommend hunting for the ones we’re going to describe in the next few sections of the guide.

S-Tier Weapons Explained

Only one weapon earns a spot at the very top in Sea of Thieves. This tier is reserved for something truly outstanding — a weapon that dominates nearly every situation. It offers deadly power, long-range control, and unmatched precision in skilled hands.

• Eye of Reach

While other tools have strengths, this one combines versatility and damage like no other. If you want a game-changing advantage in PvP or PvE, this weapon delivers. There’s a reason it stands alone in the S-Tier. It simply outperforms everything else. Moreover, Eye of Reach is considered among the best weapons in Sea of Thieves by Reddit users as well.

Eye of Reach

Out of all the best weapons to use in Sea of Thieves, Eye of Reach is at the very top so far. It rewards precision with consistent high damage. This gun also pairs well with mobility and timing, letting skilled players win fights before enemies react. Its strength lies in how it turns aim and patience into power. BLOG20

A-Tier Weapons Explained

A-Tier weapons offer strong performance in most situations without requiring perfect aim or timing. There are three weapons in this category, each bringing a different kind of strength. They’re not as dominant as the Eye of Reach, but they’re still reliable and deadly.

These picks strike a balance between power, speed, and ease of use, making them great for most players. They have their place in the Sea of Thieves weapons meta and are absolutely playable. Just make sure that they’re slightly lagging behind the weapon from the S-Tier.

Cutlass

Cutlass is a pirate’s classic and one of the most trusted melee tools. It offers fast swings, solid damage, and doesn't rely on any ammunition. You can use light slashes or charge up a powerful lunge attack to hit harder. That lunge also lets you move fast across short distances or leap into the water. It’s perfect when you’re surrounded by enemies or closing gaps quickly.

While it might take practice to master, the payoff is worth it. Skilled players can chain hits, break defenses, and stay aggressive in close range. Cutlass is simple, efficient, and always dangerous in the right hands.

Blade of Souls

Blade of Souls brings a fiery twist to swordplay in Sea of Thieves. Each swing sets enemies ablaze, causing burn damage that lingers after impact. It’s a powerful melee option that combines knockback and Fire effects, making every strike feel punishing.

You’ll need to earn this blade by defeating the Burning Blade ship. Once claimed, it can’t go into your inventory. Instead, you carry and drop it as needed, which adds risk in battle. Still, its raw damage and chaos make it worth the danger.

• Fire Damage: Hits ignite enemies, adding damage over time
• Knockback Effect: Strikes push back foes, disrupting their attacks
• Requires Burning Blade Kill: Only drops after destroying the Burning Blade world event ship
• Treasure and Weapon Combo: Functions as both loot and a tool for combat
• Must Be Carried: Cannot be stored in inventory or switched easily

Blade of Souls rewards bold players who take down tough ships and know how to handle risk. It’s flashy, deadly, and adds a layer of fire-fueled mayhem to close combat.

Flintlock

Flintlock is the most balanced firearm in Sea of Thieves and a popular pick. It’s fast enough to reload quickly and accurate enough to land solid shots. Unlike the Eye of Reach, this gun doesn’t need a scope to perform well. That makes it easier to handle in mid-range skirmishes.

It may not hit as hard as some weapons, but it’s consistent. You can land shots reliably without worrying too much about spread or aim bloom. It’s simple, effective, and a great sidearm for many builds.

Sea of Thieves Best Weapons for PvP

Choosing the right gear can make all the difference in PvP combat. You only get two weapon slots, so each choice really matters. The best PvP setups combine quick hits, reliable range, and strong pressure tools. Check out a list of Sea of Thieves best weapons for PvP in particular:

1. Eye of Reach: Delivers huge damage from a distance with great accuracy for picking off enemies
2. Cutlass: Fast swings interrupt attacks and keep enemies under pressure in close range
3. Flintlock: Offers reliable shots at medium range with fast reload and no spray
4. Throwing Knives: Quick to use, deadly when retrieved, excellent for hit-and-run tactics
5. Blunderbuss: Strong knockback makes it ideal for boarding fights and keeping foes off your ship

Most players favor weapon combos that balance melee and ranged power. Mobility, reload speed, and knockback also play a role during close encounters or ship fights. Combining weapons like Eye of Reach and Cutlass covers both long and short range. Pairing a Flintlock with Throwing Knives gives speed, control, and surprise. BLOG20

What Influences Sea of Thieves Weapons Meta

Sea of Thieves meta constantly shifts as new updates bring balance changes and gear. What’s considered top-tier today might drop in popularity tomorrow. A few core elements always shape which weapons stand out across PvP and PvE:

Conclusion

This wraps up our tier list for Sea of Thieves best weapons, fellow pirates! No matter how you sail, having the right weapon can change everything. The best tools in Sea of Thieves aren't just about damage. They're about timing, tactics, and picking what fits your style.

Some weapons thrive in chaos, others shine with careful aim. From the steady Cutlass to the deadly Eye of Reach, knowing what to bring makes all the difference. As the meta shifts with each season, stay sharp, experiment often, and trust your gut. Out on the seas, every shot and slash counts. Choose wisely – and don’t miss.

F.A.Q.